We take a look at three of the most popular compact sedans to help you decide which best fits your lifestyle.
With thousands of vehicles in our inventory, we’re here to help make car research easier for you. We’ve partnered with car-review experts from Edmunds to weigh in on what matters most when you’re looking to buy a truck or car.
***
The compact sedan may not be America's first choice when shopping for their next car, but these small cars remain popular, especially with first-time buyers. Three of the most popular sedans still available, the Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, and Nissan Sentra, all offer some combination of affordability and good fuel economy while being a lot easier to park than a big SUV.
Independent reliability tracker RepairPal® says the Corolla is the most reliable of the three sedans, but the Civic is close and the Sentra isn't too far behind.
As for prices, a used Civic will cost the most, followed by the Corolla, with the Sentra costing thousands less on average. But is this a case of getting what you pay for? Or can the Sentra make a case for itself? We're focusing on 2024 model years for this comparison.Honda Civic Basics
Honda redesigned the Civic in 2022, and it's been one of Edmunds' favorite sedans ever since. It's available as both a traditional sedan and a hatchback, with four different engine combinations, two of which are apportioned to the sporty Si (standard manual transmission) and the ultra-sport Type R, but we won't get into those today. Honda introduced a hybrid engine to the lineup for 2025, which Edmunds has reviewed very positively. So if that's important to you, check out a newer model.
Toyota Corolla Basics
The latest Corolla generation debuted in 2020 and received a big update in 2023 that included a more modern infotainment system and some styling updates. This sedan is also available as a hatchback and has two engines: a standard four-cylinder engine and a hybrid. Both get impressive fuel economy, but neither will be accused of being "powerful" or "fun." Higher-trim Corollas come with some fun styling tweaks, but the base LE model comes very well equipped with standard adaptive cruise control and forward collision mitigation.
Nissan Sentra Basics
This generation of the Sentra kicked off in 2020 and ran until 2025, with Nissan introducing a new version of the Sentra for 2026. It comes just as a sedan and with one engine, a four-cylinder engine that is the least powerful available among these three vehicles. The Sentra is bare-bones in the base S trim, but it's often available as a used car at a much lower price than the Civic or Corolla, meaning it's easy to stretch to higher trims with more features.
Honda Civic vs. Toyota Corolla vs. Nissan Sentra
We've got the basics out of the way. Let's get into the comparison.
Passengers and cargo
All three of these vehicles offer seating for five with similar, but not identical, stats. The Civic has a little more rear legroom than the Sentra or Corolla, but we're only talking about a couple of inches. Headroom is also very similar between the three sedans. The Civic wins for cargo space, but again, it's narrow. That's all in sedan configuration. What about hatchbacks?
This is a blowout. The Civic hatchback offers 24.5 cubic feet of cargo space (1 cubic foot is about the size of a standard grocery bag) compared to 17.8 cubic feet for the Corolla hatchback. The Sentra offers 14.3 cubic feet of cargo space (there is no hatchback). Best of all? This doesn't impact rear legroom on the Civic (it does on the Corolla). If you're going to get the Civic, I recommend the hatchback.
Jake's take
If you're open to a hatchback, the Civic runs away with it. If you're strictly looking at sedans with a traditional trunk, I still give the edge to the Civic, but it's very close.
Fuel economy
This is also quite close, at least when it comes to standard gas-powered engines. The standard engines in these three sedans get between 32 mpg and 35 mpg,
with the Corolla coming out on top. That's a victory, but a narrow one. The real win comes via the hybrid powertrain that's available on the Corolla, which offers an EPA-estimated 50 mpg in combined driving.As noted earlier, the Civic added a hybrid to its lineup for 2025, and Edmunds reviewed it very favorably. That's great, but there's still a downside: It's only available on the top two trims of the vehicle, whereas you can get a much less expensive version of the Corolla Hybrid. The Sentra, sadly, does not offer a hybrid at all. Its standard fuel economy is competitive, but without a hybrid, it's no match for the competition.
Jake's take
Even if you consider the 2025 Honda Civic, the win has to go to the Toyota Corolla.
How does it drive?
I'm not going to bore you with horsepower or torque numbers. Let's keep it simple: The base Corolla engine has more horsepower than the base Civic or any Sentra model. However, the Sentra was the quickest of the trio in Edmunds' testing. And if you're actually interested in a more powerful engine, the Civic has much more variety on offer than the Sentra or Corolla.
Of course, that's not all there is to a pleasant drive. Edmunds' editors found the Civic to be the best-handling of the three, meaning that when you turn the steering wheel, the car changes direction quickly and as expected. None of these cars is particularly quiet, though Edmunds testing found the Civic to be the quietest while idling. It was also the loudest at full throttle, with the Sentra being noticeably quieter.
Jake's take
If you're only looking at the base engine, go with the Sentra. If you're looking at any of the Civics with a more powerful engine, that is the way to go.
Tech
These three vehicles are modern enough that tech isn't as big a dividing factor as it used to be. All three cars offer Apple CarPlay® and Android Auto™ as standard features, and all three are rated well by Edmunds for both the breadth and the implementation of their tech features. But Edmunds' editors noted the touchscreens in the Sentra and Corolla could be laggy and slow to respond compared to the Civic.
The Corolla and Civic come with a more generous package of driver aids on their base trims, including adaptive cruise control, but even that is added on the second-tier trim on the Sentra. Edmunds noted these features worked quite well across the board.
Jake's take
The Civic takes the win here, though I wouldn't call this category a deal-breaker.
Worth the Extra Price?
The Civic can cost thousands of dollars more than the Sentra, so is it actually that much better? It depends on your budget and what you value, but it also depends on what you want out of your sedan. Do you want a fun-to-drive hybrid with tons of storage space? Then you should check out a 2025 Civic. Are you just looking for inexpensive wheels to get you from point A to point B? The Sentra is probably just fine. And if you want to split the difference? Check out a Corolla Hybrid.
Jake Sundstrom has worked in the automotive industry since 2017 and written hundreds of car related articles over the course of his career. Jake is an editor at Edmunds, where he helps produce the best used car content on the web. He has also contributed to the National Hot Rod Association and other motorsport publications. When he's not writing about cars, he's probably driving them to his next vacation; he's still working out how to get a Wrangler from Los Angeles to Maui.
