01

People are passionate about their cars.

Brand Loyalty | CarMax

For many Americans, buying a car is one of the most important purchases in their lifetimes. And the features of a car can even reflect your personality: are you outdoorsy with an all-wheel-drive, an industrious worker with a large truck, or a speedster in a sports car?

How loyal are people to their brand of car? Perhaps you had a great experience with your car and you’ll buy that brand for the rest of your life. Or what if you care most about getting practicality and features, and would happily drive any brand? We’ve worked with millions of customers over the years, and are in a unique position to answer the question of how loyal people are to their car brands. Using our data, we explored which cars people own at trade-in and what they purchase as their next car. Do they stay with the same brand or not? Are people loyal to the same type of car they used to drive (i.e., do SUV owners keep buying SUVs or do they switch to sedans)?

Based on our data, we found that the brand with the most loyal owners is Lexus, followed by Mercedes-Benz and then Ford. The brand with the least loyal owners is Volkswagen, followed by Mazda and Volvo. A Lexus owner is four times more likely to buy another Lexus at CarMax than a Volkswagen owner is to buy another Volkswagen at CarMax.

And the type of vehicle with the most loyal purchasers? The SUV: 61 percent of CarMax SUV owners get another SUV, the largest margin for re-purchase of any vehicle type.

***

To calculate car brand loyalty, we looked at every CarMax purchase from January 1, 2017 through December 31, 2017 that also had a trade-in vehicle. We then compared the brand of the purchase with the brand of the trade-in to calculate loyalty.

On average at CarMax, people are not very loyal to their car brands. Among our customers who traded in a car, just 19.4 percent of them continue on with the same brand. The rest try something different.

How often do used car buyers stay loyal to brands | CarMax

With that context in mind, the loyalty rate among different car brands can vary substantially at CarMax. So which car manufacturers have the most loyal owners? The following chart shows the repurchase rate at CarMax of each major car brand. The list is ordered from brands with the most to least loyal followings.

Which Car Brands Have the Most Loyal Owners? | CarMax

Lexus, a luxury brand perennially honored for its reliability and high customer satisfaction, takes the top spot with the most loyal CarMax owners. 30.4 percent of people that trade-in Lexuses at CarMax go on to choose another Lexus from CarMax. In second place is Mercedes-Benz, a company also well known for its luxury vehicles and customer satisfaction.

Car loyalty isn’t just for owners of luxury automobiles. Toyota and Ford each make the top five in terms of repeat-buyers at CarMax.

People may be loyal to their car brands to varying degrees, but how loyal are they to the particular car they drive? The following list shows the makes and models with the highest repurchase rate based on purchase/trade in data at CarMax from January 1, 2017 through December 31, 2017.

Which Car Makes do Owners Repeat Buy? | CarMax

Given the opportunity to buy almost any car offered at CarMax, 30.7 percent of Corvette owners go on to purchase another Corvette from CarMax. Drivers are also loyal to SUVs from Lexus and Cadillac; trucks from Ford, Dodge, and Chevrolet; and minivans from Kia, Toyota, and Chrysler.

Lastly, we thought we’d look at vehicle type. If someone drives an SUV, sedan, truck, or another type of car, how loyal are they to continue to repurchase that type of car. The final chart shows the percentage of owners who are the most (and least) loyal to their type of car at CarMax from January 1, 2017 through December 31, 2017.

Which Type of Car Has the Highest Loyalty? | CarMax

By a large margin, SUV owners are most likely to continue to buy the same style of car at CarMax; 61 percent are satisfied enough with that style of vehicle to get another. Sedans are the body type with the next-highest repurchase rate at CarMax — 47.5 percent.

Two-door vehicles tend to have the lowest repurchase rate; just 5.9 percent of two-door hatchback owners repurchase and just 8.7 percent of two-door truck owners go on to buy another two-door truck. Notably, four-door passenger vans (minivans) and four-door wagons also have low repurchase rates at CarMax.

***

Americans may love their cars, but they also like switching cars. After trading in their old car, over 80% of CarMax buyers decide to try a new brand. However, CarMax customers who buy a Lexus and Mercedes-Benz are the most brand-loyal. And CarMax customers who drive Corvettes and SUVs are also likely to stick with that kind of car.