Best-selling Used Luxury Sports Cars
Check out CarMax's best-selling used luxury sports cars.
We've compiled the 10 most popular used luxury sports cars with CarMax customers, covering a broad range of styles and prices. Learn more about how we ranked our list.
1. BMW M440
CarMax owner rating
2. BMW Z4
CarMax owner rating
Pros
Two available engine options
Luxurious interior appointments
Manual transmission offered for enthusiasts
Cons
No AWD option
Some driver-assistance features are not standard
Limited in-cabin storage and trunk space
3. BMW M340
CarMax owner rating
4. BMW M2
CarMax owner rating
Pros
A genuine blast to drive
Still offers a manual transmission
Cool interior with massive displays
Cons
Rear seats are only acceptable for toddlers
Steering wheel buttons removed for screen controls
Exterior is a visually loud
5. Porsche Taycan Electric
CarMax owner rating
6. Porsche 718 Cayman
CarMax owner rating
Pros
Fantastic handling
Fun available six-cylinder engine option
Wide range of options
Cons
Disappointing base engine
Limited on tech
Options can quickly push up the price
7. BMW M3
CarMax owner rating
8. Porsche Boxster
CarMax owner rating
Pros
Excellent handling
Engaging engine options
Artfully designed cabin
Well-insulated soft top
Cons
Weak standard stereo
Poor rear visibility
Cargo space split between two small trunks
9. Porsche 911
CarMax owner rating
10. Porsche Cayman
CarMax owner rating
Pros
Fantastic driving dynamics
Surprising storage capacity
Impressive automatic transmission
Cons
No six-cylinder option
Some competitors offer rear seats
Price climbs quickly with options
Ready to find your next sports car?
How we ranked this list
To create our "Best Of" lists, our analysts looked at CarMax vehicle and sales data over a recent 6-month period, from December 2025 through May 2026. Looking back over a 6-month period allows for the highest sample size possible while also providing up-to-date pricing information. Some articles may include data points with lower sample sizes.
We hope you found this information helpful. This content is intended to inform and is not meant to indicate that a particular vehicle is currently available or recommended for you.
Statements of fuel economy or EV range are based on EPA and other third-party estimates for vehicles when new. Fuel economy and EV range will degrade with time and vary based on age, driving conditions, vehicle history, and other conditions. See fueleconomy.gov for more info.
Unless otherwise noted, information related to featured vehicles comes from third-party sources, including manufacturer information. Product and company names may be trademarks or registered trademarks of third-party entities. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by these entities. By clicking on any video links, you will be taken to a third-party site maintained by YouTube, Inc.
We make every effort to provide accurate information, but please verify before purchasing.